Humidity Control: A tool for reducing microbial growth
Martin Ginty, 蒙特全球制药行业总监
Martin Ginty, Pharmaceutical industry director of Munters
郑丽丽,蒙特中国制药行业应用工程师
Lili Zheng, Pharmaceutical industry application engineer of Munters
摘要/ Abstract:
有害微生物的生长一直困扰着许多行业领域,尤其是食品和药品制造商。它们无处不在且难以消除,不断地威胁着人类的健康。霉菌的生长与环境的温度和湿度有着密切的关系,只要将环境的温湿度控制在合理的范围内便可有效抑制霉菌的生长。若湿度控制能将相对湿度控制在50%以下,那么所有微生物的生长都会受到抑制。蒙特在湿度控制领域拥有60多年的丰富经验,已经推出了一系列的解决方案,在任何规模的生产或存储设施中,均可通过降低相对湿度抑制微生物的生长。
Unwanted microbial growth is an ever-present problem in many areas of industry, particularly for food and pharmaceutical manufacturers. They are ubiquitous and difficult to eliminate, constantly threatening human health. Moulds growth and environmental temperature and humidity have a close relationship, as long as the environmental temperature and humidity control in a reasonable range can effectively inhibit moluds growth. Humidity control that reduces the relative humidity below 50% will stop all microbial growth. With over 60 years of experience in the field of humidity control, Munters has a range of solutions to control microbial growth by reducing the relative humidity level in any size of production or storage facility.
关键字/Key Words:
微生物无处不在 健康效果 水分 相对湿度 蒙特 湿度控制专家
Microbes everywhere Health effects water vapour relative humidity Munters Humidity control specialist
Unwanted microbial growth is an ever-present problem in many areas of industry, particularly for food and pharmaceutical manufacturers. While stringent hygiene procedures, climate control and staff awareness all help to hold microbial growth in check, humidity control is another valuable weapon to add to the arsenal of potential counter-measures.
It is an inevitable fact that no matter how hard you try to keep a manufacturing space clean, the world of microbes is continually working against your efforts. While not every microscopic invader is potentially harmful, it does make sense to make the production and storage environment as unwelcoming as possible so they cannot gain a foothold.
To get a feeling for the extent of the challenge, did you know that there are between 10,000 to 1,000,000 fungi spores per cubic meter in the air you are breathing right now? These spores can survive without moisture, remaining dormant for years are even decades. When moisture and a food source become available, the spores germinate and rapidly multiply. They do not even need liquid water to grow, even the moisture present in solid materials or humid air can be sufficient. Uncontrolled mould growth can quickly lead to product quality being compromised, and production areas needing extensive cleaning procedures. For example, the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations estimates that 25% of the world's food crops are affected by mycotoxins (poisonous by-products from moulds), resulting in the loss of one billion metric tons of food every year. So any countermeasures that can reduce the growth of mould and other microorganisms will improve profitability and reduce time spent on corrective actions.
不受控制的霉菌滋生会迅速造成产品质量下降,生产区域需要采取全面的清洁措施。例如,据联合国粮食与农业组织(FAO)预计,全球有25%的粮食作物感染了霉菌毒素(霉菌分泌的有毒副产物),每年造成的粮食损失达10亿公吨。所以,任何能够控制霉菌和其它微生物滋生的对策都会提高企业的利润,减少应对措施所耗费的时间。
People who are sensitive to mould, or who already suffer from allergies, asthma, or have compromised immune systems and occupy damp or mouldy buildings are at an increased risk of health problems such as inflammatory and toxic responses to mould spores, their by-products and other volatile organic components.
A person's reaction to mould depends on:
Their sensitivity and other health conditions
Amount of mould present in the area
Type of mould or mould by-products
Length of exposure
The most common health problem is an allergic reaction while severe reactions are rare but possible. Some moulds, such as Stachybotrys chartarum, also produce mycotoxins that can pose serious health risks. Exposure to high levels of mycotoxins can lead to neurological problems and in some cases death.
Moisture is needed for any growth to occur but moulds do not need droplets of water to form - water vapour concentrations of greater than 80% relative humidity are sufficient.
Fig 1. Effect of relative humidity on mould growth
Source: http://www.ibp.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/ibp/de/documents/Publikationen/Fachzeitschriften/mold_growth_predictiontcm45-35017.pdf
Once the relative humidity level drops below 65%, the probability of mould growth approaches zero. If the relative humidity level of indoor spaces is not controlled, there can be fluctuations during the course of the day and seasonal variations that will increase the risk of mould flourishing.
Once established, some moulds can transport free water to dry areas. In addition, moulds can be highly hygroscopic due to their large surface area. The result is that water molecules are filtered directly from the air. This process is particularly enhanced when mould develops on cold walls.
Fig 2. Effect of temperature on mould growth
Source: http://www.ibp.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/ibp/de/documents/Publikationen/Fachzeitschriften/mold_growth_predictiontcm45-35017.pdf
Whereas reducing relative humidity shows a marked reduction in the probability of mould growth, changes in temperature has a less drastic effect, particularly when taking into account the preferred comfort range of 20°C / 68°F to 25°C / 77°F for human operators in manufacturing and storage areas.
The figures shown are previously are generalisations of mould growth to allow some visualisation of the potential problems. The actual characteristics for each type of mould are different. Some examples are shown in Fig 3. and 4.
Fig 3. Isopleths of growth rate and germination for Aspergillus restrictus
Fig 4. Isopleths of growth rate for Aspergillus ruber & Stachybotrys chartarum
Source: http://www.ibp.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/ibp/de/documents/Publikationen/Fachzeitschriften/mold_growth_predictiontcm45-35017.pdf
While the information in Figures 1 and 2 present general, worst-case growth probability, Figures 3 and 4 show that the 3 types of mould selected do not approach these general growth and germination levels. Therefore, using a worst-case approach will ensure that the majority of mould growth stops at a sufficiently low relative humidity level.
Building materials can also play a part in the growth and germination times, in general materials that are prone to storing moisture (e.g. wallpaper, fabrics) will provide a better substrate for microbial growth.
Moisture is essential for microbes to grow, so be aware of any potential sources of water vapour in the manufacturing area:
From the air / water vapour
Ingression
Construction moisture
Cleaning processes
Product and production process
By-product of combustion (gas heating, engines)
Packaging
Raw materials
Production staff
Excess moisture due to insufficient heating and ventilation
Bad insulation, especially in the area of thermal bridges
Accidents and unplanned incidences e.g. Spillages
Leaks
Extreme weather
Mould growth happens anywhere when there is moisture and a food source available, and often this takes place in hard to reach places:
Cold water piping behind equipment, cabinets or partitions
Air handling ductwork with either 70%+ relative humidity or water droplets caused by excessive cooling
Under plant and storage equipment
In clumps of dirt, dust and waste that might accumulate out of sight
In ceiling tiles
On exterior walls and doors
Around windows
In general, ambient or treated air above 50% relative humidity will allow some level of microbial growth to take place. Condensation on cold surfaces will increase this growth.
Fig 5: Probability of mould growth as relative humidity changes
Humidity control that reduces the relative humidity below 50% will stop all microbial growth. Higher relative humidity levels (up to 70%) will slow growth, and this may be acceptable depending on the local environment, product being produced, cleaning processes, etc. Temperature control alone is not sufficient as some microbes are specialised to survive temperature extremes. It should be noted that dehumidification and normal air treatment will not remove existing microbes or spores in the environment – that problem will always be present. Using appropriate filters will reduce the amount of spores leaving the air handling system:
Fig 6: Sizes of common outdoor airborne particles
Fig 7: Filter types and their effectiveness against varying particle sizes
There are particular challenges with chilled stores in the 2 to 8°C / 35 to 46 °F temperature range. If humidity is not controlled then relative humidity within the chilled space can be >90%. Cold surfaces will allow condensation to occur and if this condensation is left untreated additional issues can arise. For example, in chilled spaces water droplets will tend to form on the lighting fittings and ceiling near the fan outlet of the chiller units, as well as on the chiller units themselves. These droplets occasionally drop, and these drops have the potential to carry any mould, bacteria or yeast growths present from the ceiling to surfaces below, resulting in a potential cross contamination problem. Luckily, this is easy to treat with humidity control.
With over 60 years of experience in the field of humidity control, Munters has a range of solutions to control microbial growth by reducing the relative humidity level in any size of production or storage facility. Humidity control is a valuable addition to commonly used cleaning strategies for maintaining aseptic and non-aseptic working areas, and should be considered at the design phase of any new facility. It can also benefit existing facilities that are experiencing any of the problems described above, and also be deployed when changes to the moisture load within the manufacturing or storage area occur as a result of increased production, changes to building ventilation or external environment.